Is sustainable travel only for the rich? | Travel

This time last week the cost of seeing a Komodo dragon in the wild was £11. This week it’s £208, following a staggering 1.791 per cent rise in entry fees to Indonesia’s Komodo National Park. It follows a 733 percent rise in entry fees at Borobudur, 650 miles west of Komodo and the largest Buddhist temple complex on earth.

Bhutan, which was never cheap, reopens on September 23. Following a policy review, foreign tourists will now have to pay the government a sustainable development fee of £165 per day — up from £54 — to explore the land of the Thunder Dragon.

Indonesia and Bhutan are niche destinations a long way away, but there’s growing concern that these and other recent price hikes herald the beginning of the end of the golden age of cheap travel.

The cost of tiger safaris has increased by 123 percent since 2019

MANOJ SHAH/GETTY IMAGES

In Thailand the deputy prime minister, Anutin Charnvirakul, told his tourism industry last month not to be tempted to discount in order to attract tourists. “We cannot let people come to Thailand because it’s cheap,” he said. “Hold your ground. Sell ​​premium. The more expensive, the more customers.”

In the Galapagos a plan to quadruple the £77 entrance fee is on hold while authorities monitor post-pandemic visitor numbers, and in India the cost of tiger safaris has increased by as much as 123 per cent since 2019. In Peru it may only be the slow recovery of the trekking industry that has kept Inca Trail permit prices at 2019 levels.

November’s Cop27 conference in the Egyptian resort of Sharm El Sheikh, however, could trigger more price hikes as authorities come under public pressure to be seen to be taking action, and overtourism is a popular, headline-grabbing target.

“Nobody wants a world where travel is a preserve of the privileged,” said Jarrod Kyte at Steppes Travel. “But the current low-value, high-volume model is not only broken but also risks jeopardizing travel’s legitimacy as the climate crisis worsens.”

In the Galapagos a plan to quadruple the £77 entrance fee is on hold

In the Galapagos a plan to quadruple the £77 entrance fee is on hold

MARKUS GEBAUER PHOTOGRAPHY/GETTY IMAGES

Africa offers a glimpse of the direction of travel. Botswana and Rwanda have long pursued the high-cost, low-volume model, funding conservation while controlling visitor numbers by charging sky-high prices. In 2017 the cost of a 40-minute encounter with a mountain gorilla in Rwanda’s Virunga National Park doubled to £1,240.

“Africa is moving back towards being untouchable for many,” said Rob Slater at Safari Consultants. “The best way to protect the wilderness is to manage numbers and the way in which the land is explored, while at the same time ensuring that the local custodians and the local governments benefit enough from tourism to support and prioritize conservation initiatives. However, it is such a shame if genuine nature lovers can’t get to see the beauty of Africa because there are no reasonably priced options. But who wants to run a lodge for £250 per person per night when everyone else is charging £1,100?”

“The losers here are clearly those on a lower budget, whether they’re backpackers, families, those eking out funds for a long sabbatical or anyone traveling on a tight budget,” said Jonny Bealby at Wild Frontiers. “Has this made travel more exclusive and a pursuit of the super-rich? Not really, in our view. As with everything it is about priorities — some of our clients will place travel as their No 1 priority and save up to fund that dream trip come what may.”

“Lowering the environmental impact of tourism must be a priority for any destination,” said Raki Phillips, tourism chief of Ras al Khaimah, the so-called Nature Emirate. “But quick fixes like price hikes are a blunt instrument. Better to develop a long-term strategy that benefits environments and communities while also protecting travelers.”

At Borobudur in Indonesia, entry fees have risen by 733 percent

At Borobudur in Indonesia, entry fees have risen by 733 percent

ANDRAS JANCSIK/GETTY IMAGES

And not just rich travelers, said Pru Goudie, director at Adventure Travel Networking. “When he raised the environmental levy, the Bhutanese prime minister, Lotay Tshering, said his aim was to ‘get a set of tourists who are intellectually high-standing, knowledgeable and conscious of our needs and unique features’. But ‘rich’ doesn’t necessarily mean intellectually high-standing and knowledgeable,” she said.

Turning the world’s wildest and most beautiful locations into ghettos for the wealthy not only excludes a vast section of the traveling public. It also compromises the livelihoods of the guides, hoteliers and restaurateurs in those places who serve the budget end of the market, thus contravening at least five of the UN’s sustainable development goals.

There is a smarter, more inclusive way to fight overtourism, says Delphine King, chief executive of the Long Run, an association of nature-based tourism businesses focused on sustainability.

“Optimizing the positive impact of tourism by creating livelihood opportunities, revenue, support and maintaining interest while minimizing access is a very delicate balance,” she said. “But creative approaches could be considered, including fixed-price permits and lottery-based access for more inclusivity and income generation.”

In the meantime, further increases in access, permit, trekking and environmental fees seem inevitable — especially in those Instagram hotspots — and, combined with rising flight prices, they could force your dream trip into the realms of fantasy. The best advice, then, is to book now before the dream drifts out of reach.

“The industry is battered and riddled with debt, so everyone wants maximum income with least possible complications,” Slater said. “This is understandable, but dangerous if it becomes the norm. Covid may just have truly swept out the last of the genuine old-school ways.”

■ Would you pay more for travel to ensure it was sustainable? Let us know on Twitter @TimesTravelin the comments below or by writing to [email protected]

Back to top button
MONTAGNEDISTRIBUTION